Mr. Alagiri Goes to New Delhi
(Language Discrimination in Parliament)
TAMIL TRIBUNE, October 2010 (ID. 2010-10-01); Updated: 2017-07-01.
CBSE - Central Board of Secondary Education
DMK - Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (a political party in Tamil Nadu)
1. What Happened?
M. K. Alagiri from Tamilnadu became India's Chemicals and Fertilizers minister in mid-2009. He does not know Hindi and his English proficiency is limited. He avoided attending parliament because he could not speak in the parliament or fully understand what was going on. Some opposition parliamentarians and his critics ridiculed him saying that he was not doing his job and not competent to be a minister.
It was reported in September 2009 that he asked the speaker of parliament Meira Kumar permission to speak in Tamil [which could be translated to English and Hindi] [The Hindu newspaper: September 15, 2009]. The speaker delayed and delayed making a decision. Alagiri mostly stayed out of parliament during this period. Finally after ten months, in July 2010, Meira Kumar made her decision. Alagiri's request to speak in Tamil was denied because the Indian constitution says that ministers reply to questions in English or Hindi. She said that Alagiri could answer the primary question by reading out the reply in English and the supplementary questions could be answered by his deputy minister Srikant Jena [The Hindu newspaper: July 18, 2010]. In essence, Alagiri would play the part of a "dummy" reading a reply in English [obviously written by someone else] and secondary questions would be answered by his deputy in English or Hindi [Alagiri may not understand what his deputy was saying]. Why go about this roundabout route which essentially makes Alagiri no more than a showroom doll in parliament. He could as well stay out of parliament because he is not contributing anything in the parliament--just reading an already written reply in English and sitting there the rest of the time not fully understanding what was going on.
A Hindi region minister who knows only his/her mother tongue Hindi could fully participate in parliamentary affairs but a non-Hindi minister who knows only the mother tongue is reduced to a dummy or a showroom doll in parliament. [The foregoing sentence is not meant to insult minister Alagiri. We are merely pointing out the discriminatory nature of the rules of the parliament.] Speaker Meira Kumar could have handled the situation in a way that would not hurt anyone but allow Alagiri to carryout his ministerial responsibilities. Translate minister Alagiri's Tamil reply to English which in turn is translated to Hindi. After all non-Hindi MPs' questions in their mother tongue are translated to Hindi and English. Do the same for non-Hindi ministers' answers also. Speaker refused to do so citing that the Indian constitution does not say that ministers can speak in any language other than Hindi or English.
Constitution could have been amended to allow non-Hindi ministers to speak in their mother tongue, if they cannot speak in Hindi or English. Indian constitution has been amended over a hundred times in the past 60 years. Why not amend it once more? Because Hindi politicians do not want other languages getting equal status to Hindi. There is no other reason.
We are not saying violate the constitution; we are saying, "Amend the constitution to allow non-Hindi ministers to speak in their mother tongue". Some politicians say that there are too many languages to let ministers to talk in their own mother tongues. Members can talk in about 20 languages in the European parliament. Number of languages listed in the Indian constitution is also about the same. So what is the problem? The technology is there. But Hindi politicians do not want to give up their privileged status.
If a Hindi minister can speak in his/her mother tongue in parliament, then a Tamil minister should also be able to speak in his/her mother tongue. The technology is available as evidenced by European Parliament proceedings.
First Update (July 2914)
After the 2014 election, the new minister of external affairs and the minister of water resources took their oath in Sanskrit [New York Times: June 17, 2014] . Sanskrit is not an official language of India; it has the same status as Tamil in the constitution. Obviously there is no constitutional impediment to ministers using a language other than Hindi or English. So we wonder why Ms. Meira Kumar prevented Mr. Alagiri from speaking in Tamil? Seems like an unconstitutional discrimination of Tamil.
Second Update (September 2014)
It was reported on August 8, 2014, that Minister of State for Commerce Ms. Nirmala Sitharaman was allowed to answer a Tamil question in Tamil in parliament [the Economic Times: August 8, 2014]. This is a one-time deal to assuage the mounting criticism in Tamil Nadu against some Hindi imposition actions of the new Indian government [Reference 1]. Ms. Sitharaman knows English well and has been answering questions in parliament in English all along. This is just a charade to takes Tamil people's attention of the strident Hindi imposition activities by the newly elected (2014) Indian government. [I am writing this sentence in July 2017--almost 3 years after the above incident. In these 22 months, neither Ms. Sitharaman nor any other minister spoke in any language other than Hindi or English. This proves our point that the 2014 Tamil use was just a ruse to divert attention from Hindi imposition activities.]
We have seen the bait and switch tactic before. There was mounting pressure in Tamil Nadu that Tamil be allowed in Madras High Court. One judge allowed Tamil in one case. Months later when another lawyer used Tamil, another judge refused it quoting rules and regulations. What we want are laws or parliamentary rules enacted guaranteeing that ministers can speak in the mother tongue without seeking permission from anybody; the same right Hindi ministers have. We are not begging for favours, we are demanding our right.
Archived articles on Opposition to Hindi Imposition in India (OR Search the internet with the following key words: Hindi imposition India Thanjai Nalankilli )
Alternate spellings of Tamil names: Alagiri - Azagiri, Azhagiri; Thanjai Nalankilli - Thanjai Nalangkilli
If you would like to translate this article to Tamil for us, please write us. Your help would be greatly appreciated.
This is a "Category B" article. Free to publish as long as the entire article (or translation), author's name and Tamil Tribune name and URL (http://www.tamiltribune.com) are included (no permission needed). Click here for more details.
FIS100928m - 2010-a1d